A criminal defense investigator finds and documents the facts that bear on a case: witnesses, records, physical evidence and timelines. VTPrivateye is licensed in Vermont, New York and New Hampshire, and works with defense counsel and civil litigators. We take state, federal and capital matters, from the first interview through trial.

VTPrivateye is a licensed investigation firm that works with defense attorneys and civil litigators across Vermont, New York and New Hampshire. If you are counsel looking for a defense investigator, this page explains what we do and how. The rest of our work for attorneys is on the Legal & Corporate Clients page.

What does a criminal and civil investigator do?

We find facts and put them in a form a court can use. For the defense, that means witness interviews, records, scene work and a timeline of events. For civil cases, it means the same fact-finding for plaintiffs or defendants. Our team has investigated more than 5,212 criminal and civil cases.

When do attorneys call us?

We support a case from start to finish, from the first facts to the evidence a pre-trial motion depends on. Typical needs:

  • Witnesses who have not been found or have not been interviewed.
  • Records that have to be pulled, organized and checked.
  • A client’s account that needs corroboration, or an alternate theory that needs testing.
  • A case where the story behind the client matters as much as the charge.

How we investigate

  1. Listen first. We start with your account of the case and what you need to prove or rebut.
  2. Assign an investigator. We match the case to the investigator best suited to it.
  3. Do the fieldwork. We interview witnesses, canvass, document scenes and research records.
  4. Report in writing. You receive clear written work product.

We know how to build rapport with witnesses. Richard Rubin put it this way after a motor vehicle death case. Our team got witnesses across the Northeast Kingdom to talk and to understand why their help mattered.

How is the work built for court?

Our investigators work ethically and with the courtroom in mind. Our licensed investigators are as comfortable on the stand as they are in the field.

What you receive

  • Written summaries of witness interviews.
  • Records and documents, collected and organized.
  • A timeline and a memo on the open questions in the case.
  • Support for pre-trial motions and for testimony at hearing or trial.

If the case calls for it, the same firm can add sentencing mitigation videos, jury focus groups or help to locate a missing witness.

Where we work

We are licensed in Vermont, New York and New Hampshire, with our office at 11 Main St in Vergennes, Vermont. We also support legal teams elsewhere on video and focus-group projects.

Who leads the work

Susan Randall founded VTPrivateye. She has investigated hundreds of civil and criminal cases, including federal and capital defense, and has served as an investigator for the Vermont Federal Public Defender’s office. Nick P. leads field investigation, and Fabien A. and Wyatt S. work state felony and criminal defense cases. See how we work for the full process, or read what attorneys say about us.

Call +1 802-316-8982 or schedule a consultation, and we will tell you what we can find out and what it takes.

Criminal & Civil Investigation: common questions

What does a defense investigator do?

A defense investigator works for the defense team to gather and test the facts of a case. That means locating and interviewing witnesses, collecting records, visiting and photographing scenes, building a timeline, and writing up what was found so counsel can use it. The investigator also checks what the other side says happened against the evidence. Everything is done at the direction of the attorney, and the written work product is built to hold up if the investigator has to testify.

Do you work on federal and capital cases?

Yes. Susan Randall has investigated hundreds of civil and criminal cases, including federal and capital defense, and has served as an investigator for the Vermont Federal Public Defender's office. We work with CJA-appointed counsel and federal defenders as well as private defense lawyers, and our licensed investigators also handle complex state felony cases. These matters usually need more records, more witnesses and a longer timeline, so we scope the work with counsel at the start and adjust as the case develops.

Can you interview witnesses who won't talk to the police?

Sometimes, and no one can promise it. A witness who will not talk to the police may still talk to a defense investigator, and the choice is always the witness's. We know how to develop rapport and build trust with witnesses. Richard Rubin, Esq. described our team chasing down witnesses in a motor vehicle death case all over the Northeast Kingdom. He wrote that we got them not only to talk but to understand why their help was needed. What each witness says goes back to counsel.

Do you work for civil plaintiffs and defendants?

Yes. Our licensed investigators work civil cases as well as criminal ones, including personal injury and other disputes. The work is the same kind of fact-finding: witness interviews, records research and timelines. Whether we can take a given side in a given matter depends on who else is involved, so tell us the parties first. We can add other services to the same file, such as surveillance, jury focus groups or a Day-in-the-Life video, so counsel works with one team.

Need an Investigator?

Have a Case? Need Clarity?

CALL NOW: +1 802-316-8982 Contact us