Facts Uncovered. Stories Told.
Results Delivered.

We are licensed private investigators based in Vergennes, Vermont, serving Vermont, New York, New Hampshire and beyond. We investigate and help strategize high-stakes criminal, civil and individual cases, and we help you develop a counter narrative: a different, more accurate story to tell the court.

VTPrivateye team members reviewing documents together

We are...

Investigators. Storytellers. Advocates.

We bring a breadth of backgrounds rarely found under one roof: seasoned investigators, researchers, journalists and documentary filmmakers.

Our work spans criminal and civil investigation, litigation prep, family court, jury focus groups, juror research, process service, surveillance, background checks and visual storytelling.

Whether we're preparing a case for trial or finding answers for a family, we bring compassion, strategy and persistence to every case.

Learn more about us
5,212+
criminal and civil cases investigated
56+
jury focus groups conducted
68+
sentencing and settlement videos produced
28 years
serving Vermont, New York & New Hampshire

Why Choose VTPrivateye?

What Sets Us Apart

We know how to build rapport and trust with witnesses. We dig deeply for facts and connect them. We write clear, thorough reports. Our licensed investigators are as comfortable on the stand as they are in the field, and attorneys have brought us their hardest cases for 28 years.

Full Service

Our team handles everything: jury research, video production, background checks and field investigations, from the first interview to the final report.

Multi-Disciplinary Team

With backgrounds in law, journalism, film and forensic psychology, we bring perspective and well-rounded insight to every investigation.

Courtroom Ready

Our investigations are ethical and conducted with the courtroom in mind. Our work product stands up under the toughest scrutiny.

Trusted by Attorneys

Lawyers across Vermont, New York, New Hampshire and beyond rely on us to investigate their toughest cases.

How We Investigate

1. Listen
First

We start by hearing your story and understanding the complexities of your case.

2. Assign Investigator

We match you with an experienced investigator best suited to the challenge.

3. Get
Answers

Through fieldwork, witness interviews and records research, we dig deeply and report what we find in clear, organized work product.

Criminal, Civil or Family Court Matter?

EXCELLENT Based on 10 reviews
Google
  • Rom

    Amazing team! Highly recommend!

  • Hermann Chan

    We engaged VTPI in our investigation and we found them to be professional in their approach and also sensitive and responsive to our needs along the way. The issue was concluded successfully thanks to their assistance. We would highly recommend their service.

  • ejk2911

    I love the results so far. Very detailed.

  • Clay Drinwater

    Susan and team provided exceptional investigative services for me. They were kind, responsive, and validating throughout the course of the investigation. I won’t hesitate to use their services again in the future!

  • Ritchie Berger

    They were very professional, timely and creative in handling my assignment. Highly recommend their services.

  • Ember Tilton

    Very thorough investigations and professional staff. VTPrivateye is among the best in the state bar none.

  • Amelia Silver

    VTPrivateye is my go-to investigative firm. Susan Randall and her team are quick, responsive, and thorough, but more significantly, they are attuned to social and personal nuances and the complexities of all varieties of humans. I trust them to conduct meetings and interviews with people in the most sophisticated and sensitive manner. They never let us down! And if you need a film-- a day in the life film for a lawsuit, for example--Susan and her collaborating film directors can create a compelling visual narrative.

  • Samson Hansen

    VTPrivateye provides tireless advocacy for their clients. With over two decades of investigative experience Susan Randall has managed to put together an incredible team, spanning multiple generations with a depth of legal knowledge and tech savvy young investigators. VTPrivateye's skills range from background checks to field surveillance and sentencing mitigation.

Trusted by law firms and clients throughout Vermont, New York, and New Hampshire.

  • Gravel & Shea
  • Langrock Sperry & Wool
  • Barr Law Group
  • Maguire Law
  • Odaodowan Delince
  • Sullivan-Brill
  • Biggam Fox & Skinner
  • Dinse
  • Sheehey Furlong & Behm
  • Harding & Mazzotti

News

Podcasts & Articles Featuring VTPrivateye and Related Topics

More Articles

Vermont Private Eye

This is an interview with a very old friend of mine, and the person who trained me as a private investigator. She taught me everything from basics like how to look up criminal records to the very advanced skills I learned. Susan Randall has been a PI in Vermont for fifteen years. She works on some of the biggest cases in the state…and she’s really good.

Susan on the Train Tracks

Susan Randall has been a private investigator in Vermont for twenty-four years. She defends people who are accused of crimes, which often involve drugs, in one way or another. This summer she was robbed by a person with a terrible heroin addiction, and it made her really angry, and really tired. This is that story.

What Class Are You Susan?

This series started as an experiment a few years ago. I wanted to have conversations with people about the terrible cultural divides that keep growing in our country, without ending up in boring conversations about politics…

Need an Investigator?

Have a Case? Need Clarity?

CALL NOW: +1 802-316-8982 Contact us