Susan Randall is the founder and lead investigator of VTPrivateye in Vergennes, Vermont. A former journalist and documentary filmmaker, she has investigated hundreds of civil and criminal cases, including federal and capital defense. She has produced over fifty sentencing and settlement videos. She teaches nationally on mitigation and fact investigation.
Background
Susan Randall founded VTPrivateye 28 years ago. She graduated from Brown University and filed stories for NPR before she became an investigator. In New York she worked for the MacNeil-Lehrer NewsHour, made documentaries for A&E Television and produced documentaries for the BBC. She is a former journalist and documentary filmmaker, and the firm still works that way: investigation and storytelling under one roof.
She leads a team of licensed investigators at 11 Main St in Vergennes, Vermont, working in Vermont, New York and New Hampshire. You can meet the rest of the team on our about page.
Investigation work
Susan has investigated hundreds of civil and criminal cases. Her work includes federal and capital defense, and she has worked as an investigator for the Vermont Federal Public Defender’s office. That work includes finding witnesses and getting them to open up and speak with us.
Attorneys hire her for criminal and civil investigation. Her specialties are criminal defense, mitigation, sentencing videos and strategy. If you want to know how a case moves from that call to a report, see how we work.
Mitigation and film
Susan has produced over fifty sentencing and settlement videos. A sentencing video tells a judge or prosecutor who a person is and how their life led to the case. It covers mental health, childhood and the people who shaped them. A settlement video shows what an injury does to an ordinary day.
She works with collaborating film directors on these projects, and the work is described on our pages for sentencing and mitigation videos and Day-in-the-Life videos. The firm has produced 68+ sentencing and settlement videos in all.
Teaching and professional leadership
Susan teaches nationally about mitigation and fact investigation. She is President of the Vermont Association of Investigative and Security Services.
In the press
Susan is the subject of five podcast posts on our blog, hosted by a friend whom she trained as an investigator. Older episodes give her years as a Vermont investigator as of when they were recorded, so the figures differ.
- Vermont Private Eye. An interview with the person who trained the host as a private investigator, covering everything from looking up criminal records to advanced skills.
- Susan on the Train Tracks. A story about a summer when Susan was robbed by a person struggling with heroin addiction, and what it did to her.
- What Class Are You Susan? An episode from a series of conversations about the cultural divides that keep growing in the country. It steers clear of a political argument.
- Driving Around With Susan. Again! A conversation about working on a sentencing case for a high-profile multiple-murder in Vermont, and what the work is like after a case closes.
- Driving around with Susan. A second interview recorded while driving around Vermont, about the criminal justice system and about parenting.
What attorneys say
Ian P. Carleton, a Vermont civil and criminal defense attorney, describes working with Susan for more than two decades:
“I have been working on cases with Susan for over 23 years, since long before she incorporated VTPrivateye. I am not alone among Vermont trial lawyers in saying my first phone call is to Susan when I need serious investigative work performed in any of my cases. From casing out Hell’s Angels–controlled wood chipping factories in northern Canada to locating a reluctant witness hiding in a North Carolina trailer park, Susan brings to her work a blend of problem solving, grit and creativity I have not found in any other investigator. She was instrumental in obtaining an acquittal in my first federal criminal trial back in 2002, similarly crucial to our DNA-based exoneration of John Grega in 2012 after he spent 17 years in jail for a crime he did not commit, and has provided invaluable assistance to me in a variety of other civil and criminal litigation based situations since then.”
Ian P. Carleton, Esq., Vermont Civil & Criminal Defense Attorney
Amelia Silver, a New York and Vermont attorney, says of the firm’s film work:
“If you need a film— a Day in the Life film for a lawsuit, for example—Susan and her collaborating film directors can create a very compelling visual narrative.”
Amelia Silver, Esq., New York and Vermont Attorney
Testimonials reflect individual matters. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
More attorney comments are on our testimonials page. To talk with Susan’s team about a case, contact us or call +1 802-316-8982.